

Reynolds Transfer & Storage
2.6 out of 52.6(5 reviews)as of 2026-09-21
Listed·Movers·Madison, WI·reynoldstransfer.com
Get a quote
Haulest is not a carrier. We connect you to movers. We do not dispatch a truck.
About this mover
- Address
- 725 East Mifflin StreetMadison WI 53703Wisconsin
- Website
- reynoldstransfer.com
- USDOT
- 077949
- MC
- 67234
- Operates in
- WI
- Reviews on record
- 5, newest 2019-09-26
From the licensed record. Haulest has not visited this address and is not a carrier.
Licence
USDOT 77949 · MC-67234
Matched to the licensed record. Registered is not the same as authorized for household goods. Check the snapshot.
Review highlights
“professional” comes up in 3 reviews of Reynolds Transfer & Storage.
People also searched for
Reviews
Dated rows only. Movers cannot pay to add, alter, or remove a review here. Licensed rows carry a small source label. Reader reviews are read by a person before they go live. How we handle reviews.
Your nameYour citySelect your ratingStart your review of Reynolds Transfer & StorageOverall rating
2.6 out of 52.6
5 reviews on record · as of 2026-09-21
- 5 stars2
- 4 stars0
- 3 stars0
- 2 stars0
- 1 star3
Patricia K.
Source: MoveAdvisor · Cambridge, WI to Madison, WI
3-bedroomPaid $2,000
Local move time 2 plus temporary storage.
I used Reynolds for 2 local moves and temporary storage of my belongings while my house was finished. Everyone involved was professional and courteous and very pleasant. They were careful with my possessions and were quick to respond to a scratch on one table. I was able to get some used boxes from them to help with packing. Would definitely recommend them ad use them again if I need to.
Eagan H.
Source: MoveAdvisor · Madison, WI
2-bedroomPaid $500
Great movers.
Everything as planned. On time and professional. Will use them again. We had some heavy stuff and they didn't even blink.
Erin
Source: MoveAdvisor
Paid $8,000
Delivery - Apparently whenever they feel like showing up.
At this point, we were told that all of our furniture was to arrive today.. we have our 3 month old and 2 year old in a child care center for the day, our dog out at doggy daycare for the day in an effort to make this as smooth as possible for the movers. We were called at 10:15 am on the day they were to arrive to be informed that they were instead coming on Monday. When asked for an explanation, our contact, Gaylene, told us we would have to figure that out with the driver. This is incredibly unacceptable, especially given the price we are paying. We chose a United Van Lines affiliate because we believed that they would be reliable. This, so far, is ridiculous. .
Ann
Source: MoveAdvisor
Paid $4,000
Misinformation from office.
Reynolds told me they could fit me on the day I needed to move. They planned to send someone out to give an estimate, 2 days after my first call to them. I expressed concern that I would lose a slot while waiting for the estimate but was reassured that wouldn't happen. I had used Reynolds in the past and wanted to give them my business, so I put two other movers on hold while waiting to hear the Reynold's estimate. A very kind and professional woman, La Rae, showed up and explained that they could only move me on the Saturday (double time) several days prior to my move, and weren't available to move me on my requested day. She spoke to the person who I first contacted per phone but apparently that person was helpless to fix this. I will now try to secure another mover but wasted two days based on Reynold's misinformation.
Calbert A.
Source: MoveAdvisor
Paid $21
Worst move ever had.
We had the worse experience you can imagine with this company. We already moved 4 times in 15 years and this was the worse and most expensive. Let me give you some details: A) Packing of household property : One member of the crew broke a glass vase and unfortunately, my wife cut her foot. We expect that small accidents can happen during packing and moving of the household but we expect to be promptly notified so we can clean the damage and prevent personal injury. We were very concerned since we have a 9 year old, a 5 year old and a 17 month old that walked barefoot though the house!!. A member of the crew packed "forbidden" cleaning products such as opened bottles of bleach, ammonia, aerosols and other chemicals. We had to unpack those ourselves and notified the crew leader. The master bedroom clothing was not appropriately packed since the shoes were placed on top of clean clothes without any paper in between, causing unnecessary stain of the clothing. Silk ties were thrown all together with belts in a box causing damage to the former piece of clothing. Kids markers, some of the them without the cover and unwrapped in paper, were also thrown in boxes mixed with towels causing staining. The United crew from our destination (this was a long distance move) found the furniture poorly padded and indicated that was the reason to find damage and severe scratches to several pieces of our furniture. The carpet of the house was not appropriately covered and protected with consequent significant staining. A sales person came to our house to see that damage and recognized the error. She asked us to clean it ourselves!! B)Transport of the household: Unfortunately, all our household property was not loaded in a single truck as we were told. The driver indicated that this issue happens frequently during that time of the year since it is very busy for moving companies. I was told that I should not worry since the overflow load was going to be delivered at the same time than the main load. The initial load was delivered within those dates but not the rest of the household as were told. It arrived 10 days later! The inventory of the first load was incorrect and there were over 50 items without tag (more than can be blamed on transportation issues). Several items were missing and it was unclear to us if they were going to be present in the overflow load. This caused additional and unexpected expense. A critical item for us was the vacuum cleaner since 3 of our family members have asthma and our new house had carpet in all the rooms. The vacuum cleaner was one of the items missing in the original inventory. My 5 year old son started to become symptomatic and we were authorized by Reynolds to purchase a vacuum and we were told that we would be reimbursed. C) Transportation of the automobiles: Our contract was signed for two different ways to transport and delivery of our two cars. The first car was supposed to be delivered within 5 days (at a premium price). Both cars were late. The worse part was the manager agreed to reimburse us for additional expenses such as the vacuum, dry cleaner bills and broken items.I was quite naive to pay them after Reynolds agreed to reimburse us for the additional expenses. Months past by and the manager stop answering my calls and complaints. They only paid the pieces of furniture that were damaged but they are not planning to reimburse for all the additional expenses that we agreed before I paid the bill. The worse part is they are not even answering my phone calls or emails.
Haulest is a research desk and quote line operated by Panaweb LLC. We are not a carrier.